Fortis Capital Solutions GPM Disposition PortfolioLocation Intelligence & Lease Summary
← All properties
Rank #20 of 143 Strong 67/100

Village PantryStore #2282 · Village Pantry

10655 N Michigan Rd, Zionsville, IN

Annual Base Rent$328,675
Rent $/SF$65.77
Building SF4,997
Land (ac)2.79
Remaining Term2.9 yrs
StatusMid-Term
Pre G&A CFC3.63x

Lease Abstract

Tenant / d/b/aVillage Pantry
GuarantorFas Mart (GPM Investments)
Lease commencementMay 25, 2007
Lease expirationMay 31, 2029
Remaining term2.9 yrs
Lease term (months)
Annual base rent$328,675
Base rent $/SF$65.77
Rent at expiration
Expiration rent $/SF
Renewal options1/1
Notice dateSep 03, 2028
Year built1998
Building SF4,997
Land area (acres)2.79
Pre G&A CFC3.63x (2024)
Lease statusActive

Location Score Breakdown 67/100

AADT Traffic 2/15
Highway Proximity 10/10
Gas Competition 1mi 2/15
3mi Population 10/12
3mi HH Income 12/12
Pop Density 3mi 4/8
County Growth 7/7
County Unemp. 7/7
Dollar Stores 6/6
Daytime Jobs 3mi 8/10
EV Density Pen. 0/0
Thin Market Pen. 0/0

Trade-Area Demographics

Metric1 mi3 mi5 mi
Population040,222120,148
Households016,92847,075
Pop. density (/sq mi)01,4231,530
Avg HH income$161,517$159,167
Poverty rate7.1%7.7%
Bachelor's+ 65.6%62.0%
Median home value$419,071$409,050
Median rent$1,798$1,617
Median age3938
Owner-occupied62.2%64.5%

Site & Market Detail

Traffic (AADT at site)4,450
Daytime jobs (3 mi)43,842
Daytime jobs (1 mi)7,331
Gas competitors (0.5 mi)1
Gas competitors (1 mi)5
Dollar stores (0.5 mi)0
Highway distance (mi)0.01
EV stations (5 mi)16
CountyHamilton County
County pop. growth8.8%
County unemployment2.8%
Walk score56
Bike score71
FEMA flood zoneX

Investment Highlights

  • The 3-mile average household income of $161,517 places this site among the top-tier suburban convenience store locations in the Midwest.
  • GPM Investments, backed by ARKO Corp. with approximately 3,500 locations across 34 states, provides publicly traded, SEC-reporting lease credit of demonstrable scale.
  • Hamilton County's 8.8% population growth from 2020 to 2024 supports long-term demand for convenience retail at this location.

Key Risks

  • At 4,450 AADT, site traffic is well below the threshold most institutional buyers target for fuel-dependent convenience formats, pressuring fuel volume assumptions.
  • With only 2.9 years of remaining lease term and a single one-year renewal option, rollover risk is immediate and renewal optionality is limited.
  • Five competing gas stations within one mile create a saturated competitive environment that constrains pricing power and customer capture rates.

Executive Summary

This Village Pantry / Fas Mart (GPM Investments) net lease asset at 10655 N Michigan Rd, Zionsville, IN sits in a high-income suburban corridor within Hamilton County, one of the fastest-growing counties in the Indianapolis metro. The property earned a location grade of 67/100 (Strong), reflecting solid trade-area fundamentals offset by moderate site-level traffic and near-term lease rollover risk. Buyers should underwrite this as a short-term income play with optionality dependent on tenant renewal.

Demographics

The 3-mile trade area posts average household income of $161,517, median home value of $419,071, and a bachelor's degree attainment rate of 65.6%, indicating a highly affluent, educated suburban consumer base. Population within 5 miles reaches 120,148 at a density of 1,530 per square mile, supported by 43,842 daytime workers within 3 miles. Poverty rates below 8% across all rings reinforce the quality of the surrounding customer profile.

Market Context

Hamilton County has grown 8.8% from 2020 to 2024, reaching 379,704 residents, within a metro exceeding one million people and carrying a 2.8% unemployment rate. The county supports 10,169 business establishments and 164,274 employees, reflecting a mature, diversified economic base. This is among the strongest suburban infill markets in the Midwest for convenience retail.

Location Quality

The site sits 0.01 miles from a major road with 4,450 AADT, which is modest for a fuel-and-convenience format that typically relies on higher pass-by counts. Twenty restaurants and 20 retail destinations within one mile provide complementary traffic generators. Five competing gas stations within one mile represent meaningful pressure on fuel volume and margin.

Risk Factors

The FEMA flood designation is Zone X, presenting minimal environmental exposure. No violent or property crime data was available at the state level for independent verification, which limits full risk underwriting. Physical obsolescence is a consideration given the building was constructed in 1998 and is now over 25 years old, potentially requiring capital investment at or around lease expiration.

Investment Positioning

With 2.9 years of remaining term expiring May 2029, this is a mid-term net lease approaching rollover. The current rent of $328,675 annually ($65.77 per square foot) is a meaningful data point, but the absence of rent at expiration data limits yield-on-cost analysis at renewal. GPM Investments, LLC, as a subsidiary of Nasdaq-listed ARKO Corp., the sixth-largest U.S. convenience operator with roughly 3,500 locations, provides institutional-grade credit backing. Buyers accept near-term re-leasing or renewal risk in exchange for a strong guarantor covenant in a high-quality suburban market.

Full institutional offering memorandum with all 48 briefs, maps, and tax analysis.

Download full OM (PDF)
← PrevAll propertiesNext →